Car Accident Claims Guide: Settlement, Insurance, Fault & Your Rights

Over 6 million police-reported traffic crashes happen every year on American roads.¹ More than 2.4 million people get injured.¹ You're reading this because you're probably dealing with one right now.

Here's what nobody tells you upfront: the insurance company that's supposed to pay your claim? They're not on your side. Their adjusters are trained professionals whose job is to pay you as little as possible. They do this thousands of times a year. You've done it zero times.

This guide levels the playing field.

Who this is for:

• You got hurt in a crash that wasn't your fault (or wasn't entirely your fault)
• An insurance company is already calling you
• You're trying to figure out what your case is actually worth
• You're wondering if you need a lawyer or if you can handle this yourself

What you'll walk away knowing:

• Exactly what to do in the first 72 hours (most people blow this)
• How insurance companies calculate settlements (and how they lowball you)
• What determines fault and why it matters for your payout
• When a lawyer is worth the 33% fee, and when you're better off alone
• Your state's deadline to file (miss it and you get nothing)
• The mistakes that kill claims before they start

This isn't a sales pitch. It's the information insurance companies hope you never find.

What To Do Immediately After a Car Accident

The first ten minutes after a crash set up everything that follows. What you do right now, while you're still shaking, determines whether you get paid fairly six months from now.

The First 10 Minutes

Check for injuries first. Your health matters more than your claim. Check yourself, then check your passengers. If anyone's seriously hurt, don't move them unless there's an immediate threat like fire or oncoming traffic.

Call 911. Even for fender benders. A police report creates an official record. Some states require you to report any accident involving injuries or damage over a certain dollar amount. Without a police report, it becomes your word against theirs.

Move to safety if you can. If your car still drives and you're blocking traffic, pull to the shoulder. Turn on your hazards. If the car won't move, get yourself and your passengers away from traffic. Standing next to a disabled vehicle on a highway is how secondary accidents happen.

Do not apologize. This is where people mess up. Don't say "I'm sorry." Don't say "I didn't see you." Don't say "I should have been paying attention." Anything you say becomes ammunition later. The other driver's insurance will use your own words to reduce what they pay you.

Get their information. You need: full name and phone number, insurance company and policy number, driver's license number, license plate, vehicle make, model, and color.

At-the-Scene Checklist

Your phone is your best evidence-gathering tool. Use it before you leave.

Take photos of: every vehicle from multiple angles, all visible damage (close-ups and wide shots), the intersection or road where it happened, traffic signals, stop signs, lane markings, skid marks and debris, your visible injuries (bruises, cuts, swelling), their license plate and insurance card.

Write down: names and numbers of any witnesses, the responding officer's name and badge number, police report number (ask for it), exact location (intersection, mile marker, address), weather and road conditions, time of the accident.

Don't do this: don't discuss who was at fault, don't sign anything except what the officer needs, don't accept cash on the spot to "settle it right here," don't leave without police documentation.

When to Go to the Hospital

Get to an ER or urgent care if you feel head pain, confusion, or dizziness; neck or back pain (even mild); difficulty breathing; abdominal pain or tenderness; numbness or tingling anywhere; or vision problems.

Here's the thing: even if you feel fine, get checked within 24 to 48 hours. Adrenaline is a powerful drug. It masks pain. Whiplash symptoms often don't show up for two or three days. Concussions can seem like nothing at first. Internal bleeding doesn't always announce itself.

Seeing a doctor immediately also creates a paper trail linking your injuries to the accident. If you wait three weeks to see someone, the insurance company will argue the crash didn't cause your problems.

The First 72 Hours After a Crash

These three days matter more than most people realize. The foundation of your entire claim gets built right here.

Day 1: Medical Documentation

If you didn't go to the ER, see a doctor today. Be thorough about reporting symptoms. Don't downplay anything. Tell them about pain anywhere, even if it seems minor; stiffness or trouble moving normally; headaches; trouble sleeping; difficulty concentrating; mood changes or anxiety.

Here's why this matters: your medical records become your evidence. If you don't mention a symptom to your doctor, it doesn't exist as far as your claim is concerned. Toughing it out costs you money.

Day 1-2: Call Your Insurance Company

You need to report the accident to your own insurer. Most policies require this. Keep it simple: when and where the crash happened, who was involved, that you have injuries and are getting treatment.

Stop there. Don't speculate about fault. Don't guess about how bad your injuries are. Don't agree to a recorded statement yet. Don't accept any offer they make.

You're required to report the accident. You're not required to hand them everything they want on day one.

Day 2-3: Document Everything Else

Get a copy of the police report. Take more photos of your injuries as bruises develop. Get a repair estimate for your vehicle. Start a folder (physical or digital) for every receipt and document.

Early Mistakes That Destroy Claims

Most claim-killing errors happen in the first 72 hours:

Waiting too long for treatment. A gap between your accident and your first doctor visit gives insurance companies an easy argument: if you were really hurt, why'd you wait?

Posting on social media. Insurance investigators monitor Facebook, Instagram, TikTok. That photo of you smiling at your nephew's birthday party? They'll use it to argue you're not actually injured. Stay off social media during your claim. Entirely.

Giving a recorded statement to the other driver's insurance. You don't have to do this. They work for the other driver, not for you. Every question is designed to find something they can use against you.

Taking a quick settlement. That offer they make in the first week? It's a lowball. They're hoping you'll grab the money before you realize what your case is actually worth.

Common Car Accident Injuries

Understanding what injuries look like helps you recognize symptoms and make sure you report everything to your doctor. Some injuries are obvious. Others take days or weeks to surface.

Soft Tissue Injuries

These affect muscles, tendons, and ligaments. They're the most common car accident injuries and also the most disputed by insurance companies because they don't show up on X-rays.

Whiplash happens when your head snaps forward and back. Your neck muscles and ligaments get stretched or torn. Symptoms include neck pain, stiffness, headaches, and sometimes numbness down your arms. The tricky part: symptoms often don't appear for 24 to 72 hours.

Sprains and strains can hit your back, shoulders, and limbs. They can cause chronic pain if you don't treat them properly.

Insurance adjusters love to minimize soft tissue injuries. Don't let that discourage you. These injuries are real, they're painful, and they can affect your life for months or years.

Spinal Injuries

Car crashes put enormous force on your spine.

Herniated discs happen when the cushioning between your vertebrae ruptures or bulges. This can cause severe pain, numbness, and weakness. Many herniated discs require surgery.

Spinal fractures range from minor compression fractures to severe breaks that threaten paralysis.

Spinal cord damage can cause partial or complete paralysis. These are among the most catastrophic injuries from car accidents.

Traumatic Brain Injuries

You don't have to hit your head to hurt your brain. The rapid deceleration in a crash can slam your brain against the inside of your skull.

Concussions are technically "mild" TBIs, but even mild brain injuries can cause headaches, memory problems, difficulty concentrating, mood swings, and sleep problems that last for months.

Moderate to severe TBI can cause permanent cognitive impairment, personality changes, and lifelong disability.

Warning signs of brain injury: headache that won't quit, confusion or memory gaps, nausea or vomiting, slurred speech, one pupil bigger than the other, any loss of consciousness, even briefly.

If you notice these symptoms, get to an emergency room now.

Internal Injuries

Internal injuries don't show on the outside. That's what makes them dangerous.

Internal bleeding can happen from blunt force to your abdomen. Watch for abdominal pain, dizziness, or fainting.

Organ damage to your liver, spleen, kidneys, or lungs needs immediate medical attention.

Delayed Symptoms

Many injuries don't announce themselves right away. In the days and weeks after your accident, watch for new headaches, neck or shoulder pain that develops later, back pain, numbness or tingling, abdominal pain, personality changes, and sleep problems.

If new symptoms appear, see a doctor and make sure they know about the accident.

Who Pays After a Car Accident?

Understanding who's financially responsible determines where your money comes from. The answer depends on fault, insurance coverage, and your state's laws.

The At-Fault Driver's Insurance

In most situations, the driver who caused the accident has insurance that pays for your medical bills, your lost wages, your pain and suffering, and your vehicle damage.

This is a "third-party claim" because you're going after someone else's policy.

The catch: insurance only pays up to the policy limits. If the person who hit you only carries $25,000 in coverage and you have $100,000 in damages, you've got a problem.

Your Own Insurance

Your policy might cover certain things regardless of who caused the crash:

Medical Payments coverage (MedPay) pays your medical bills up to a limit, no matter who was at fault. Not every policy has this.

Personal Injury Protection (PIP) is required in "no-fault" states. It covers your medical expenses and sometimes lost wages, regardless of fault.

Collision coverage pays to fix or replace your car, minus your deductible.

Uninsured and Underinsured Motorist Coverage

Uninsured motorist (UM) coverage protects you if the person who hit you has no insurance. About 14% of drivers nationally are uninsured (that's 1 in 7).² In some states, it's over 25%.²

Underinsured motorist (UIM) coverage kicks in when the at-fault driver's insurance isn't enough. If you have $100,000 in damages and they only carry $50,000 in coverage, your UIM policy can cover the gap.

Other Parties Who Might Be Liable

The driver isn't always the only one responsible. Employers can be liable if the driver was working at the time. Vehicle manufacturers can be liable for defective parts. Government entities can be liable for dangerous road conditions. Bars and restaurants can be liable under dram shop laws if they over-served an intoxicated driver.

How Fault and Liability Are Determined

Fault determines who pays and how much. Here's how insurance companies and courts figure it out.

Police Reports

The police report is usually the starting point. It contains the officer's observations at the scene, statements from both drivers, witness statements, a diagram of how the accident happened, any citations issued, and sometimes an opinion about who was at fault.

Important caveat: police officers don't make final fault decisions. Their reports are evidence, but insurance adjusters and courts make the ultimate call.

Evidence That Establishes Fault

Insurance adjusters look at police reports, photos and videos (traffic cameras, dashcams, bystander footage), witness statements, physical evidence like skid marks and damage patterns, cell phone records, and vehicle "black box" data.

Comparative vs. Contributory Negligence

What if both drivers share some blame? Your state's law determines how this works.

Pure Comparative Negligence (13 states including California, New York, Florida): You can recover damages reduced by your percentage of fault. If you're 30% at fault with $100,000 in damages, you get $70,000.

Modified Comparative Negligence (33 states): You can recover only if you're less than 50% at fault (or 51% in some states). Go over that line and you get nothing.

Pure Contributory Negligence (Alabama, Maryland, North Carolina, Virginia, DC): If you're even 1% at fault, you recover zero. This is the harshest rule in the country.

Insurance Company Tactics

Insurance companies are businesses. Publicly traded ones with shareholders who expect profits. They make money by collecting premiums and paying out as little as possible.

Knowing their playbook helps you not fall for it.

The Quick Settlement Offer

Within days of your accident, sometimes within hours, an adjuster calls with a "generous" offer to settle everything right now.

Why they do it: they want to close your file before you understand what your case is worth. Early offers are almost always a fraction of the true value.

Never accept a quick offer before you know the full extent of your injuries. Some injuries take weeks to show up. Once you sign a release, you can't come back for more money when your condition gets worse.

The Recorded Statement Request

Adjusters ask for a "recorded statement" about the accident. They make it sound routine. Just need it for the file.

What's actually happening: they're looking for anything they can use against you. The questions are designed to get you to say something that sounds like admitting fault, downplay how hurt you are, or contradict something you said in the police report.

You are not required to give a recorded statement to the other driver's insurance. Decline politely.

Delay Tactics

Time works against you. Insurance companies know this. The longer your claim drags on, your bills pile up, you get desperate for money, you're more likely to take whatever they offer, and you might miss the deadline to sue.

If they're requesting the same documents repeatedly, "losing" paperwork, or just not returning calls, they're running out the clock.

Medical Minimization

Adjusters routinely challenge your treatment: "That MRI wasn't medically necessary." "Six months of physical therapy is excessive." "Your symptoms are from a pre-existing condition, not this accident."

They hire doctors to review your records and write reports supporting lower settlements. These doctors work for the insurance company. They're not looking out for you.

Surveillance

For larger claims, insurance companies hire investigators. They follow you. They take video. They watch your social media.

That photo of you lifting your kid at the park? They'll argue it proves you're not really injured. That check-in at the gym? Evidence you're faking.

How Car Accident Settlement Value Is Calculated

Understanding how settlements get calculated helps you evaluate offers and know when you're being lowballed.

Economic Damages

These are your actual out-of-pocket losses. They're relatively easy to add up.

Medical expenses include: emergency room bills, hospital stays, surgery, doctor visits, physical therapy, prescriptions, medical equipment (crutches, braces, wheelchairs), and future medical care you'll need.

Lost income includes: wages you missed during recovery, sick days and vacation days you burned, and reduced earning capacity if you can't go back to your old job.

Property damage includes: vehicle repair or replacement value and personal items damaged in the crash.

Non-Economic Damages

These compensate for things without a direct price tag: physical pain, emotional distress, loss of enjoyment of life, inconvenience, scarring or disfigurement, and loss of consortium (impact on your marriage).

Insurance companies typically use formulas to calculate this. Two common approaches:

The multiplier method: Take your economic damages and multiply by a number between 1.5 and 5 based on severity. If you have $50,000 in medical bills and lost wages, and your injuries justify a 3x multiplier, that's $150,000 in pain and suffering.

The per diem method: Assign a daily dollar amount for every day you're affected by your injuries.

Policy Limits: The Ceiling on Your Recovery

Here's something critical that most people don't think about: you can only recover up to the at-fault driver's policy limits (unless you have underinsured motorist coverage).

If your damages total $500,000 but the person who hit you only carries a $50,000 policy, that's likely all you're getting from their insurance. It doesn't matter what your case is "worth" in theory.

The Claims Process Step by Step

Here's how a car accident claim typically moves from crash to check.

Step 1: Get Medical Treatment

Your health is the priority. But from a claims perspective, consistent medical treatment builds your case. Follow your doctor's plan. Don't skip appointments. Don't quit early.

Keep treating until you reach "maximum medical improvement" (MMI), the point where your condition has stabilized and isn't expected to get better.

Step 2: File the Claim

Notify the at-fault driver's insurance (or your own, for first-party claims). Give them when and where the accident happened, who was involved, and that you're injured and treating.

Don't give detailed statements. Don't accept early offers.

Step 3: Investigation

The insurance company investigates. They'll review the police report, take statements, look at vehicle damage, request your medical records, and possibly send investigators to watch you.

This takes 30 to 90 days for straightforward claims. Longer for complicated ones.

Step 4: Send a Demand Letter

Once you've reached MMI, you (or your lawyer) send a demand letter laying out what happened, why the other driver is liable, your injuries and treatment, all your damages with documentation, and a specific dollar amount you're demanding.

Step 5: Negotiate

The insurance company counters with a lower number. You respond. They counter again. This goes back and forth until you reach a number you can both live with, or until you hit an impasse.

Most claims settle during negotiation. No lawsuit required.

Step 6: File a Lawsuit (If Needed)

If negotiation fails, you file suit. This starts discovery (both sides exchange evidence), depositions (sworn testimony), mediation (often required before trial), and trial (if no settlement happens).

Most cases still settle after a lawsuit is filed. Only 2 to 3% actually go to a jury verdict.

Step 7: Get Paid

After settlement (or verdict), you receive payment minus attorney fees (typically 33% before lawsuit, 40% after), medical liens (money owed to healthcare providers), and case expenses.

Money usually arrives 30 to 60 days after finalizing the settlement.

Do You Need a Lawyer?

Honest answer: not always. Here's how to think about it.

When You Can Handle It Yourself

You might be fine without a lawyer if your injuries are minor and fully healed within a few weeks, liability is crystal clear (you got rear-ended at a stoplight), your damages are straightforward to calculate, the insurance company is offering something reasonable, and you're comfortable negotiating.

For small claims with obvious fault, the insurance offer might be fair. Paying an attorney 33% of a $10,000 settlement when you could have gotten $10,000 yourself doesn't make sense.

When You Need Professional Help

Get a lawyer if any of these apply:

Serious injuries. Surgery, broken bones, herniated discs, head injuries, anything permanent.

Disputed liability. The insurance company says you're partly at fault, or fault is genuinely unclear.

Multiple vehicles or parties. Complexity goes up fast when more people are involved.

The insurance company is playing games. Denying your claim, delaying forever, offering insultingly low amounts.

Low policy limits. The at-fault driver has minimal coverage and you need to explore other options.

You're overwhelmed. If the process is stressing you out and affecting your recovery, professional help is worth the fee.

Situations Where You Should Always Get Advice

Insurance denies your claim entirely. You're being blamed for something that wasn't your fault. Surgery is required. You can't work. Your injuries are permanent. Someone died. Commercial vehicles are involved (trucks, buses, rideshare).

What Lawyers Actually Do for You

Personal injury attorneys handle all communication with insurance, gather and protect evidence, calculate what your claim is really worth, negotiate with leverage and knowledge, file lawsuits when necessary, and take cases to trial if the offer never gets reasonable.

Most charge nothing upfront. They work on contingency and only get paid when you win.

Statute of Limitations by State

The statute of limitations is your deadline to file a lawsuit. Miss it and your case is dead. No exceptions.

How Much Time You Have

Most states give you between 2 and 4 years for car accident injury claims. But the range is wider than most people realize.

Warning: These deadlines apply to filing lawsuits. Your own insurance policy might have shorter deadlines for making claims. Check your policy.

The Discovery Rule

In some situations, the clock doesn't start until you discover your injury (or should have discovered it). This matters for injuries with delayed symptoms.

When the Clock Pauses

The deadline can be extended ("tolled") in certain situations: the victim is a minor (deadline often starts at age 18), the victim is mentally incapacitated, the at-fault driver leaves the state, or the at-fault driver is on military active duty.

Government Vehicle Accidents

If a government employee caused your crash (police car, city bus, postal truck), deadlines are much shorter. Many states require you to file a notice of claim within 6 months to a year. Miss that deadline and you can't sue at all.

Mistakes That Destroy Car Accident Claims

These errors reduce or eliminate what you recover. Avoid them.

Mistake #1: Skipping Immediate Medical Care

No doctor visit, no documentation. Insurance companies will argue your injuries aren't serious, the accident didn't cause them, or you're exaggerating.

Even if you feel okay, get checked within 24 to 48 hours.

Mistake #2: Gaps in Treatment

Starting treatment, then stopping, then starting again weeks later creates a "gap" that adjusters exploit. They'll argue you must have healed during that time, and anything after isn't related to the accident.

Follow your treatment plan. Don't quit early.

Mistake #3: Social Media

Insurance investigators check social media. That photo of you at a wedding, looking happy? Evidence you're not really hurt. That post about going to the beach? Proof you're faking.

During your claim: post nothing, check in nowhere, don't accept friend requests from people you don't know, and make everything private.

Mistake #4: Recorded Statements

The other driver's insurance wants you on the record. They say it's just routine. It's not. Every question is designed to find something they can use against you.

You don't have to do this. Say no.

Mistake #5: Accepting the First Offer

First offers are lowballs. Insurance companies make them before you understand your injuries, before you know what treatment you'll need, before you have any idea what your case is worth.

Never accept an offer until you've reached maximum medical improvement.

Mistake #6: Waiting Too Long

Yes, you might have two or three years to file a lawsuit. But evidence disappears. Witnesses forget. Surveillance footage gets recorded over. Your position weakens every month you wait.

Start your claim promptly.

Mistake #7: Poor Documentation

You can't prove what you can't document. Keep records of every medical visit and bill, every expense related to the accident, days you missed work, how injuries affect your daily life, and every communication with insurance.

Car Accident FAQs

Can I sue if I was partly at fault?

In most states, yes. Comparative negligence rules let you recover damages reduced by your percentage of fault. If you're 20% at fault with $100,000 in damages, you get $80,000. In a few states (Alabama, Maryland, North Carolina, Virginia, DC), even 1% fault means you recover nothing.

What if the other driver doesn't have insurance?

Your uninsured motorist coverage pays for this. About 14% of drivers nationally have no insurance.² In some states, it's one in four. If you don't have UM coverage, you can sue the driver directly, but collecting from someone with no insurance is difficult.

What if I didn't go to the hospital right away?

You can still file a claim, but delayed treatment hurts your case. See a doctor as soon as possible and explain that symptoms developed after your accident.

How much is my case worth?

It depends on your medical bills, lost wages, pain and suffering, and other factors. Generally: more severe injuries plus clear liability equals higher settlements.

Do I have to pay a lawyer upfront?

Most personal injury lawyers work on contingency. They get paid only if you win. Typical fees are 33% before filing a lawsuit and 40% after. You pay nothing out of pocket.

Should I talk to the other driver's insurance?

Be careful. Give them basic info (name, contact details, insurance info). Don't give recorded statements. Don't discuss fault. Their job is to pay you as little as possible.

What if insurance denies my claim?

Denials aren't final. You can dispute with more evidence, file a complaint with your state's insurance commissioner, or sue. An attorney can evaluate your options.

How long do I have to file?

The statute of limitations varies by state. It ranges from 1 year (Kentucky, Louisiana, Tennessee) to 6 years (Maine, North Dakota). Most states are 2 to 3 years. Don't wait until the deadline approaches.

What if my injuries got worse after I settled?

Too late. Once you sign a release, you can't come back for more money. This is why you should never settle until you've reached maximum medical improvement and fully understand your condition.

What if a commercial truck hit me?

Truck cases are more complex. Federal regulations apply. Multiple parties might be liable (driver, trucking company, cargo loader). Damages are typically higher because injuries are more severe.

What if I was on a motorcycle?

Motorcycle accidents usually mean worse injuries and face bias problems. Adjusters and juries sometimes assume motorcyclists are reckless.

Can I handle my own claim?

For minor injuries with clear liability, yes. But data shows that people with attorneys typically recover more, even after fees, especially for serious injuries or disputed liability.

What about pre-existing conditions?

Pre-existing conditions don't kill your claim. Under the "eggshell plaintiff" rule, the at-fault driver takes you as they find you. If the accident made a pre-existing condition worse, they're liable for that aggravation. Expect the insurance company to argue your symptoms are from the old condition, not the accident.

How long does a claim take?

Simple claims with minor injuries: 2 to 6 months. Moderate injuries requiring ongoing treatment: 6 to 12 months. Serious injuries or lawsuits: 1 to 3 years.

What's the difference between a claim and a lawsuit?

A claim is a request for payment from insurance. Most claims settle without court. A lawsuit is a formal legal action filed in court. You file a lawsuit if the insurance company won't pay fairly.

Will my rates go up?

If the accident wasn't your fault, your rates typically shouldn't increase. If you were at fault, they probably will. It varies by state and insurer.

What if the other driver lies about what happened?

This is where evidence matters. Photos, witness statements, police reports, and dashcam footage can all contradict their story.

Should I accept a rental car from insurance?

Yes, but know the limits. Insurance typically covers a rental only for a reasonable repair time. If they're slow to process your claim, you might have to pay out of pocket and seek reimbursement later.

What if I wasn't wearing a seatbelt?

In some states, not wearing a seatbelt can reduce your recovery. This is called the "seatbelt defense." The other driver might argue your injuries would have been less severe with a seatbelt.

What records should I keep?

Everything: medical bills and records, repair estimates and receipts, pay stubs showing lost wages, photos of injuries and vehicle damage, correspondence with insurance companies, a daily journal of how injuries affect your life.

Get a Free Case Evaluation

If you've been injured in a car accident, you may be entitled to compensation for medical bills, lost wages, and pain and suffering.

One call to find out what your case is worth.

• No obligation
• Free claim review
• Response in minutes

Get Your Free Case Review